A Guide to Filling Pocket Holes – What Works and What Doesn’t With Stain

The Kreg jig is one of the very best tools a DIYer can have in the toolbox. Honestly, I am horrible at other types of joinery so this tool is definitely made for me!

There are several ways to fill the holes (and this applies to countersunk holes, also) – Use a dowel and flush cut it, use wood filler, use Dry-Dex (a type of joint compound), or paintable caulk. I have used each and every one of those methods and they all work great when using paint on the finished project. I really wanted to know how each would work with stain. So, I decided I would experiment…

I started by filling each of the holes with a different type of filler and let them dry.


Then I stained the entire board and all four pocket holes.


As you can see, the dowel took the stain pretty well. The Dry-Dex took a little stain, the paintable caulk didn’t take it at all, and the wood filler did pretty well. (I already knew the caulk wouldn’t take it but I thought I’d try, right?)


So I guess the dowel will be the winner…

Until next time,

Happy Creating!

Designs by Studio C is your DIY connection to How-To information, DIY projects and free furniture plans. Have questions about the plans? Contact me at!
Some posts on DbSC contain affiliate links. What this means is that if the link is clicked and a sale is made, I will make a small profit. Product links and sponsored posts are what help keep DbSC going - thank you for the support!